Ok so basicaly : every situation where a trooper does not move following a guts roll (standard trooper who fail and goes prone, who pass and doesn't move, religious who pass and go prone or fail and doesn't move) As a principle why not. But I don't want to post here question who does not have an independant post. The idea is : - first people post the question in the rule forum, discuss it and end up agreeing to disagree AND/OR agreeing that a CB ruling is necessary - then I add it here with a link to the discussion so people can go there if they want to discuss it or read the argument for each side (and also so CB can move the discussion in the solved question once an answer is provided)
Concerning the Stealth and Hacking question, there was this old thread: http://infinitytheforums.com/forum/topic/43541-non-leader-fireteam-members-and-stealth/ I can't open it though. But if I remember correctly, the fireteam member still benefits from Stealth so he can't be hacked in your example.
That's because the old forum has closed: https://forum.corvusbelli.com/threads/old-forum-closing-cierre-del-viejo-foro.26844/ Note that it was originally due to close early last year.
Ok so I will use google cache : http://webcache.googleusercontent.c...embers-and-stealth/+&cd=1&hl=fr&ct=clnk&gl=fr
Damn, forgot about that cache since I didn't know the green arrow is that thing now. Always thought Google deleted that feature. :D Now I can compile and screenshot some old questions+answers before the cache got cleared some day.
please do so! You can make a compilation thread later to have all those answered questions available.
Theoretically, there should be a post for at least 50% of questions that document attempted to address, someone just need to dig those up.
Immobilized has a list of things you may not do while in the state that leaves some to be desired. Q: Hack Transport Aircraft, Change Facing and Counterstrike does not qualify for this list. Can you declare these skills? A1: Yes! You are meant to be able to interfere with enemy Hacking and airdrops while Immobilized and turning around isn't actually movement. A2: No! An ARO is a Short Skill with the only exception that it can't be declared during the Active turn unless also a normal Short Skill. Can't find the thread at the moment.
Question related to template and critical added, thanks to @inane.imp for bringing it Do you have a discussion I can link (or can you create it ?)
Made a new one: https://forum.corvusbelli.com/threads/immobilized-and-change-facing-what-is-a-short-skill.26997/
Thanks, I will leave the discussion grow a little bit then work on a summary Added Hope we will get some reponse from @HellLois. There are 13 questions in the first post plus a few more I need to add
I'm not sure it's a good idea to add stuff that's clear in the rules (being in Camo state doesn't stop you being a trooper) nor frequently asked.
True. It seemed more contentious on my first read through of the thread, but it seems fairly straight forward now.
https://forum.corvusbelli.com/threads/guts-roll-prone-and-change-facing.2021/page-2 This one could use an official stamp either way from CB. Supposedly it was solved one way or the other, but the answer resides on the old forums and no one can access that anymore.
Opinions seems to all go in the same direction here and rulles seems quite clear. Do you feel like a "CB stamp" on the answer is needed ? I think it's the same question as the one called "Gut rolls, falling prone and facing / Gut rolls, religious troop and facing" (added a few days ago to the OP) Do you agree ? If yes, I will just add your link to the existing question
