Concillium Watch is an utterly pointless rule it may as well not exist

Indeed, I have to confess I'm a pretty noob player that loose all the time. Thanks for teaching me.

Btw I'm talking about doing like 2 or 3 move-move orders. It's not that order consuming for one point without rolling a dice. I don't say it will happen all the time. I just say it's something that arise in some games. It never happened to you that the difference between a tie and a win (or between a minor and a major) is just to capture the HVT ?

 

Well maybe this just shows the corporate nature of the world of Infinity? Some weapon makers have better lobbyists in the halls of power. :D Tohaa and Haqqislam diplomats are very good at twisting the arm of O-12 mayhaps?

 

An extra Objective Point. Neither one is mandatory, and you can achieve maximum points in any missions w/o them. Where’s the problem?

 

Indeed. Thanks for spotting it. That's weird ...

Well thanks to you I will remember.

 

Players, hearing about soon-to be released N4: "Hope they streamline the game just a little bit and cut some rule bloat"

CB, a couple of weeks later: "Here's the taste of things to come!"

Honestly, I find these fluffy rules to be fine when they are included into one-off narrative scenarios. Otherwise most of them get dissected and lose their charm roughly same way Xenotechs were.

I mean, it's only something ineffectual if you score maximum points all the time, or at least if your games usually feature one player winning with a considerable advantage. But a point is a point.

Ofc I don't expect relying on that point to be a strategy worth planning for, given what it takes. May happen on some occasions if someone isn't playing attention though.

 

List makes no sense. Warcors argued about all these things but to no avail... CB response was basically we decided on these weapons on the list so deal with it.

 

I dislike the execution of the rule. That said it might add some choice as to what you do with your warcor rather than bang it on the tallest point possible and distract people with its laser pointer.

 

The reality of the matter is that this will only have an effect IF the players remember and IF the warcor is still alive on turn 3...

Dr Worm and Tamiris will have bigger chances to pull it off, since they are less sacrificial troops and have less ARO capability...

 

It doesn't really sound all that unfair or poorly tested. 1 sectorial having a disadvantage? Talk to ariadna when hacking classified come up or the mission gives a bonus to hackers. I'm willing to hold judgement until I play it.

 

Have any of you even played a single fucking game with the rule

 

Stop talking sense, it’s the Internet. Half formed assumptions is the name of the game.

 

This topic was made by the same dude who made a topic basically saying invincible army was dead on arrival like 30 minutes after the spoiler video.

 

And it turns out IA is pretty weak. Who would have said you could make predictions by looking at the rules? Crazy

 

I like it better than xenotech. Hopefully we get a journalist merc in the season.
It can be expanded upon. Is a totally optional objective which can help in tie-breakers

Liason officers though. ehhhhh. What happens if you don't want to designate an FO as a liason officer? is that a choice?

 

Doesn’t look like...

 

I'd say that these two extras are much more fair and better tested than xenotech, that's for sure. And much less annoying if you choose to ignore them - they don't slap you in the face with OP deductions just because you didn't want to waste orders on them.

 

Have my Like for saving me the effort of asking the self-same question.

 

I like the rule a fair bit, it makes people actually interested in protecting their press members instead of using them as ablative armour, and gives people the option to deny a point by playing a list without certain tools. I don't like what it does to single combat group lists though, they're already strapped for orders and have better things to spend Command Tokens on then persuading the journalist to help with the order pool.