You're falling back on that *now*, but earlier you claimed that the rules supported the gotcha point of view. So go figure - the reason you get...
What I described is literally a way to poke holes in flimsy ideas. It *is* a counterargument.
Yup, and we know that LoF can exist between a model and a point, because smoke grenades. So I'm checking enemy models' LoF to the point I want to...
Yeah, so you ask your opponent "If I were to declare a short skill and move to location x, would your model y have LoF to my model and gain an...
It's called reducto ad absurdum, and the "gotcha" argument is vulnerable to this kind of attack because it fails to consider its own practical...
Native English speakers seem to disagree, and the rules were written in English first... even if the endpoint were "play it as it lands" it still...
Given that the rules were written in English, and the vast majority of the English-speaking playerbase plays with what is functionally intent, it...
Yup. I mean, we all know I can argue. At great length. Doesn't mean I want to spend my games of Infinity doing so. Whereas a gotcha player has...
Forget skill, how wobbly the legs of the table you're playing on or how much friction the scenery pieces have with the table shouldn't be a factor...
They can be contradictory with an earlier rule, though, in which case the game is broken. And if one rule has multiple interpretations, and one...
You mean the part where it says players are expected to share all open information? The part that you don't want to follow when you say you don't...
The game plays fine with intent. Infinity is nowhere near tightly balanced enough that that actually upsets anything; I'm really confused as to...
So you think that models armed with Targetless weapons have the ability to check their LoF against more things than those without, due to their...
That clearly goes against the spirit of the Blue Box. You're required to help your opponent with LoF.
A different way of playing which has substantial negative consequences on gameplay. When moving your model a fraction of a millimeter can mean the...
Utter tripe. Infinity's ruleset isn't even precise enough for us to be sure about what the balance is; since enough of it is poorly...
Wait, this is BS too. A better analogy, with respect to science, is giving everyone a calculator, instead of requiring everybody to do all their...
Considering that the "gotcha" crows constantly flings insults our way saying that intent play is sloppy, that good players don't use intent play,...
No it doesn't. Intent play actually involved placing miniatures at a point where there LoF is accurate to what the player decides, it just figures...
The fact that the Swiss fucking Guard don't have Religious is one of the weird things about Infinity...
