Because as discussed, you don't want a rule encouraging people to just yolo swag roll it because it's inflating their odds of winning bad...
To put it simply. Expending orders to maneuver into position with the correct models to engage in an favourable firefight is good gameplay....
Using MSV2 to counter ODD and kill the ODD model isn't a stupid move. That's what you're supposed to do with it. Tarik shouting "YOLO SWAG 360...
You are quite candidly ignoring the complaint. The complaint isn't FAT2 increases your odds, like MSV or ODD or Marskmanship does. It's that FAT2...
If you need to spend 2 additional orders to fire smoke and allow Tarik to get closer into a good rangeband, to then shoot, statistically in that...
I appreciate while you want to throw insults because you don't have much of a case to stand on, it doesn't change the fact that FAT2 enables this...
That is completely incorrect. If you take the same situation and apply it to a model without FAT2 their ability to win falls off hard. For...
Because shooting AT BS4 and having a grand total of a 3% difference is good odds for what you are doing, when most other models would probably be...
Like Gregg you're not reading posts. The example was with a 39-41% odds for a different scenario not the ORC one. But that's besides the point....
Because you should not be in a good position to win a firefight at BS4 vs BS14. That is the problem with the rule is it enables a player to take...
You are not reading these posts. The coinflip is has nothing to do with your example of an ORC fireteam, but a Dakini link vs a potentially linked...
Because, again, you are firing in the good range band. The complaint about FAT2 has nothing to do with taking good firefights, it's about how it...
It's still a reasonably winnable fight is the point, far too reasonable for the BS4 vs BS17. You should not have rules enabling BS4 to have any...
Because I know a player who does just that. Constantly takes tactically unsound decisions then rides FAT2 to victory. The rule should be changed...
ODD doesn't cause big swings in ridiculous firefights. Again, you put ODD on the target firing at BS4, it only raises the odds to 21-56% in the...
You're shooting in the good range band. Change it to -6 and look at the numbers, they're far different. A BS 4 model with Mimetism instead of FAT2...
I wouldn't call complaints about increasing the effectiveness of the critical hit rule a troll post, but you do you I guess.
Uh, yeah. A a roughly 1/3 chance of winning when firing at -9 or -6 odds vs BS 17 (i.e. taking a gunfight you have no business taking) is exactly...
I mean that's a safe bet given that no other unit from IA will get a box set release. I feel like they'll forget the tinbot though and do the 4th...
I have never felt building your list to only function optimally in half the games you play is a solid strategic decision.
