I think it fair to say that the rulebook did not translate the game designer's intentions as well as it might've done, but it's not quite as...
Just a couple of self-corrections, for the record. In fact PsychoticStorm manages to clarify the question using the extant language just fine...
I'm pretty sure that in the future - when passions have cooled, people reading this forum topic will (if they don't completely lose the will to...
We know that historically, there's been an issue with 'Line of Fire', 'Facing' and 'line of sight'. In the (authorized!) video, Palanka actually...
... I think I'm not going to get into this with you (or anyone else) @Hecaton because we've both been here from the start, and I doubt we'll be...
We know that Barakiel, and no-one's saying that the PBI faction want ... their models to get an extra inch (fnar, fnar :wink:) or to claim a...
I'm very much in agreement, and I'm sure I can speak for most, if not all of the other 'rules as simply read' posters in saying we're none of us...
Yes I think it does, and in more ways than one! I myself want to make the game as accessible as possible, but that doesn't mean we should...
I think this is one of the smarter posts we've seen recently, because the lines are about as well drawn as they're ever going to be, and I don't...
Guys, please! I'm not going to answer every 'play by intent' advocate who so very ironically thinks they've caught me out with a gotcha! My post...
Yes, and it's worth going over this since clarifying formal rules and etiquette and distinguishing them from the courtesies we're developing...
So can we agree that - in this sort of situation at least, I'd be a thoroughly decent chap and welcome in the PBI camp? :smile: The difference is...
We didn't reach that conclusion. I pointed out that etiquette is - by definition, not a rule. I don't disagree that's in the rulebook or that it's...
I agree, and think it's time we tried to distinguish what 'gotcha' really means. Yes, we could say that skills like Holoecho are deliberate...
It's ok, 'Harvest; we can chat amongst ourselves, the rest are all out in their Facebook groups doing their Dark Chanting. :wink: They'll be back...
So you say. But every time I declared a BS attack today I rolled exactly 17. Again and again. And it's not like I was playing Pan O in good Range...
Yes, but all this time you'd said I could trust you, and now it's my name they're chanting in the dark rituals of their Facebook covens!
Actually, yes. :grin: It's Private Information obviously, but to demonstrate my good sportsmanship :wink: I can tell you that Fernando is...
Thank you, Brother! Yes, I think that even in the most fiercely competitive situation, a victory is meaningless if you don't agree on the rules....
Nicely said @Sabin76, that was and still is my position. I figure that once we know what the game creators intend, we have a more or less fixed...
