I don't know, I can guess. It's not the first rule in the game to feel strange. I just follow it's instructions without bias. To me that's a far...
It is unfortunate if their intent was for those profiles to function differently than what the RAW say. I wouldn't be surprised if your...
I don't think having two separate models, each with their own troop profile, on the table as separate and valid targets, is obvious that they...
Your opinion might hold more value if you provide some rules to back it up.
If the game wants me to treat both troopers as one... why don't the rules explicitly tell me how to do this? In the absence of such rules, the...
How do the rules differentiate which profile is the one used for Order generation? If the TAG generates an order while the Pilot is inside, and...
The rule stating the Manned TAG has an alternate profile with the Pilot Skill doesn't give us any instructions to follow. Nor are there rules and...
The rules in this game explain why certain troopers don't generate the orders on their profile even though multiple profiles are found in one...
At the moment, I don't have any issue with the Pilot+Manned TAG rules. But this thread is making me question if I'm missing something. This is how...
It also seems very reasonable for the pilot to generate it's own order if dismounted during the tactical phase. Spending orders to mount or...
Are you sure? It seems to me that they simply function in either state. Sometimes as one trooper using the TAG profile and sometimes as two...
I see nothing in the rules to suggest when a pilot or its Manned TAG suffers a game state or effect that the other must also suffer that state or...
I'm having a hard time following this discussion. Where are the rules governing game states being shared between pilot and TAG?
I completely understand that you find it clear. But I assure you not everyone is of the same opinion. So my statement is a valid one. To provide...
First of all, I'm not saying that. I said, and I quote, "I play it the same way you describe. But to be fair, the rules are not clear". I was not...
The situation that line refers to isn't 100% clear as I've indicated already. I'm not adding it for the reasons you describe. I'm showing how...
I agree, it is complex enough. But players are already creating this situation when it comes to intent. Players need to ask all the questions and...
I play it the same way you describe. But to be fair, the rules are not clear. It's never stated that declaring an attack on one trooper in a CC is...
I don't believe that is true for every instance of intent play. The degree of difficulty is subjective and has no baring on what the RAW allow or...
It is most definitely a house rule. What someone believes to be RAI =/= RAW.
