Because that is true only if you choose to read it that way. I agree "this state" and "it" are not defined terms so are open for interpretation....
I prefer to read it as referring to that specific models currently activated Stratuscloud state, Kondo'd! Once this state (the Stratuscloud...
Which is about as vague as the rules themselves. If his rulings are official, there should be a clear indication of this. Otherwise, it's simply...
It was meant as a heads up to not expect very much. Don't expect the ruling to actually make sense within the rules. And don't expect the ruling...
Unfortunately, an official ruling can go against what we think was their intent. It doesn't really matter how much sense we think it makes to us....
I agree to no restrictions, period, so I don't think there needs to be any outside influences either. If players/factions have trouble making...
IF the intent is for Stratuscloud to be used only once per trooper during an entire game the rules do a terrible job of telling us. I agree with...
I think the Stratuscloud can be reloaded and used multiple times. For pretty much all the reasons given in the other thread. The RAW cannot...
I'd prefer to take that approach as well. I'd like to find a way to allow players to create their list based on the mission AND terrain.
Missions are easily one of the most important things about gaming for me. I always hated the GW games in the past that were solely focused on just...
I agree their priorities seem off. However, I don't think there needs to be any set schedule for things like this. There's no reason to have any...
It has to be Option 3. There is no structure you can trust to lead you to the correct conclusion. An understanding of the English Language and...
Thanks @Ogid, I appreciate it. I really didn't expect many people to read this whole thread. Let alone decide to get involved at this stage =). I...
The roll that is made is a consequence of both players actions, I agree. But your interpretation of the rules creates a different process used to...
Be careful of bending the correct rules to fit the broken ones. It's certainly tempting to try and find a way to read the rules so there's no...
Another point. If skills like Discover were to work as you say, why does the skill mention passing a normal roll at all? This isn't proof of...
I come to those conclusions as well but via a different interpretation of the rules. I can point to each spot in the rules where it explicitly...
Wrong. I didn't contradict you by showing that there are normal rolls. I contradicted you by showing there are normal AND FTF rolls. Maybe you...
Your statement feels very nit picky. Yes, in some cases where an effect may not want to be used, 'allow' gives us the option not to use it. But...
The rules tell a different story. Discover is inherently a Normal roll. The rules tell us to pass a normal roll. This is fine of course because...
