Actually, I am quite afraid to shake this hornet's nest, but since I mentioned it on another thread, I might as well go all in. So, I am just...
I know, and considering the kind of game and community, it does not surprise me that much. I just understood the intent thing by reading a six...
I can totally get the kind of sensation you are describing and its appeal. I learned myself about most weapons types by my models being hit and...
So, I get your intentions and I see what problem you are trying to avoid, but, in my opinion, the lines are too blurry to build on top of this. Is...
@Triumph So, please argument my previous example, since I really need to understand where you stand. We are playing, I am a new player (which I...
How much is possible or not to guess what's missing is not even the point. The point is: the player at the table with years of experience is able...
Respectfully, I do not agree at all. New players are already at a disadvantage by not knowing most of the fine strategies of the game (which has...
By the number of your posts, most of you have been playing for years, so let me give the point of view of a new player: this game already has one...
Silent CCW would be very cool and probably fun to use.
If realism was really an issue we would only have drones, automatic targeting and air strikes. Not such a fun game to play :)
Just to be sure I'm getting it right: if Bob declared CC Attack he wouldn't have received any penalty since it requires no Los (so no visibility...
No, I am honestly asking what the purpose of having both HD and Liutenant on the same model if it's suicidal to deploy in HD (without this...
On the other hand, what's the purposo of a HD Liutenant if I can never deploy it in HD? I'm asking to understand not to provide a feedback, since...
From my part it was not a tricky question at all, just trying to understand how you would have dealt with someone trying to apply the rule by the...
I'm curious to know how exactly will it be ruled in events you hosts, I mean: exactly the wording of what you can and cannot do, since I don't see...
That's a nasty one. For a start, I would say that there is a difference between LoS and ZoC, since the HD state is canceled in declaration and...
Rules that were a mess and forced players to negotiate interpretations all the times drove you out of 40k. It's not up to the players to discuss...
Right. As I said, I basically just started so I'm figuring things on the go. Nice to know this one if fully inteded though :)
So really models without stealth DO have a clear edge here, since their noise if forcing a non BS ARO on everyone in ZoC. This is really something...
Anyway, the different behaviour of BS attacks brings anyway some strange interaction, if I got it right. Let's say in the example above I reach...
