Halt production on Karakuri poll

Lucky it's not my argument. This is:

Majorities have been and indeed often are, wrong. I'm not claiming anything is enforceable, so please dial back the projections there. Text you quoted is in fact the truth and not just an opinion.

 

This is literally an example of an opinion.

 

Are you denying the existence of trash Manga? Are you denying the existence of Manga that should not be used as source material for INFINITY?

Their existence is fact.

 

So why did you try to defend it if it wasn't your argument? Do you agree that the scale is wrong?
Wuji, i think you are confusing SIZE and SCALE. You keep saying scale, but really mean size.
"Despite so many people's large vocabularies, there is an extreme tendency toward hostility like lower animals, a cacophony of personal attacks and unchecked group think does not make value."
I guess, if you think people disagreeing with you is a personal attack? Have you looked at the results of your poll? Maybe you are just wrong?

 

Again, this doesn't mean they're out of scale, it means they're small.

Are they intentionally that small? Maybe. Can you dislike them? Yes of course. I have yet to see compelling evidence that this is a mistake rather than a stylistic choice though.

 

You said we shouldn't embrace it, which is your opinion. You said there is trash which is subject to taste and again your opinion. By definition that was an opinionated statement. Get off your high horse.

 

Them creating a mini that fits their vision of a unit cannot be “objectively wrong”. If I had any artistic or writing talent, and created a drawing of how I pictured the protagonist of my work, it cannot *be* wrong. Other folks might not like it, or it might not be to their taste, or they might not like the technical execution of it, but they cannot claim that I am wrong in my representation of my vision. Same here. You can pretty up your complaint any way you like, but this is a case where since they’re presenting their vision for the unit, there’s literally no way they can be wrong in their interpretation of their own vision. Again, you don’t have to like it/buy it/think it’s good/etc.

 

You're so full of yourself. Look at your poll results, most people will purchase these karakuris and CB will not lose a penny on these. And thats with a poll that was built in a way to skew the answers towards the answer you wanted to hear as much as possible.

Its perfectly fine that these be smaller than other models, they're meant to be deceptive and take their opponents by surprise.

"lure them in with cute kawaii gestures then blast their faces with a panzerfaust/chain rifle when theyre not expecting it".

 

I'm willing to submit both claims to scientific method. You can go out and disprove the existence of Boku no Piko and/or explain how it's not trash/unsuitable source material for INFINITY.

What about when they used two different characters for 'Jia' on the Guijia logo. Must we assume that their vision was for it to be simultaneously called Turtle Shell and Turtle Home? Or that they didn't double check their pinyin to hanzi conversion. CB's fumbled execution of their vision in this case does not change the objective reality that the design is wrong.

 

now youre changing your argument. Originally it was that trash anime existed. Now its that trash anime exists in the context of infinity? And Hentai isnt Anime btw. Thats like saying "You shouldnt use Marvel to make minis because porn exists"

 

Seriously get over yourself. Even if I agreed with your tastes on how things should be that'd still be my opinion along with yours. What you assert doesn't just become fact. There is no way to measure taste.

 

De gustibus non est disputandum.

 

You changed my argument with incorrect comprehension. I won't go too hard at you in case English is not your first language. But if it isn't I'd suggest putting the breaks on bold semantic claims in arguments you are not following well.
See the original statement that brought trash manga into the argument.

Does this not imply that being inspired by Manga makes the new Karakuri design less nonsensical? I was responding to it by pointing out how flawed this notion is.

You are now in a position where you must argue that the Boku No Pico Manga adaptation is not Manga. Make sure you use TOR for your research.

 

Yikes

 

No one is in a position to do anything. Again get off your high horse and stop patronizing people.