Yes, that much is obvious. This isn't going to be resolved without official CB statements clarifying how it should be played, and apparently that...
You were being lumped in with other play by intent stance people. I guess if you want to take that as a bad thing, that's up to you. /shrugs
"Ilk" just refers to similar people. It's not a pejorative term.
Looking at the table is not a measurement. Correct. Using a tool to finely check something is a measurement. And around in circles we go again...
If you can get them to publish an official blog post clearing all this up, I'm all for it.
http://wiki.infinitythegame.com/en/Order_Expenditure_Sequence "7. Resolution: Players take measurements, determine MODs, and make Rolls."
I mean, I agree that there is an issue with how Booty is written, but there's nothing unclear about how it's written, and it's completely...
Using an eyeball to estimate distance vs using a tool to measure it. Using an eyeball to estimate a Line of Fire vs. using a tool to measure it....
When you attack anyone that opposes you and spread your own gospel, it's quite easy to live in an echo chamber.
There's nothing contradictory about it. You declare AROs after the first part of the Active Order is declared (whether that is first short skill...
So you can declare to Delay an ARO against a Camo marker after the active camo declares it's first short skill. If you Delay, and the camo marker...
Why don't you guys try keeping this mess to one thread, huh?
Have you considered that "potential target" might mean a model that may be in LoF, as opposed to any point on the board at any time?
Personally I would find it concerning if the mod thought I was playing the game wrong, and I'd want to figure out where things got bunged up....
My point had more to do with the fact that reading the exact same rules, using the exact same words, could have wildly different impact depending...
What if you read it from the wiki instead? http://infinitythewiki.com/en/Open_and_Private_Information
I mean, this isn't even an important part of the discussion, it's just language semantics, but "disrupt the order" could easily be interpreted as...
Again, as I already stated, I have zero problem with this: The rules state X, but by agreement you are not doing X. Done. No argument...
Meant to respond to this part as well: This is the real frustration I have with the whole discussion here. PIWIL people aren't saying PBI is...
I mean, honestly, if you're in a tournament where things have got that bunged up, you probably SHOULD have a TO mediate quickly to make things...
