Combined Ammunitions and Immunity (total)

Tema en '[Archived]: N4 Rules' iniciado por Commoner1, 27 Sep 2020.

Estado del tema:
Cerrado para nuevas respuestas
  1. Commoner1

    Commoner1 Well-Known Member

    Registrado:
    23 Nov 2017
    Mensajes:
    202
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    373
    Does a Plasma Carbine hit force an ARM and an BTS roll for Immunity (total) or is it just one hit?
     
  2. Spleen

    Spleen Well-Known Member

    Registrado:
    28 Nov 2017
    Mensajes:
    283
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    414
    The saving attribute of a weapon is not a factor that total immunity effects, so the unit would still make 2 saves, one against ARM, one against BTS
     
  3. Terrenor

    Terrenor Active Member

    Registrado:
    2 Ene 2019
    Mensajes:
    42
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    26
    I'm sorry, but that is just wrong. Immunity total tried all ammunition typs as normal ammunition.
    And normal ammunition forces to make one ARM save.
    Plasma is the ammunition typ that force ARM and BTS roll. And Plasma becomes normal because of immunity total.
    I think the rule is pretty clear.
    20200928_122422.jpg
     
  4. Commoner1

    Commoner1 Well-Known Member

    Registrado:
    23 Nov 2017
    Mensajes:
    202
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    373
    Plasma IS normal Ammunition.

    upload_2020-9-28_12-33-22.png
     
    A Lesh' y ijw les gusta esto.
  5. ijw

    ijw Ian Wood aka the Wargaming Trader. Rules & Wiki
    Infinity Rules Staff Warcor

    Registrado:
    25 Abr 2017
    Mensajes:
    7.353
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    14.845
    Plasma is no longer an ammunition type. If you look at the weapon profile for a Plasma Rifle etc, the Ammunition that's listed is N (for Normal Ammunition). The two Rolls come from the Saving Roll Attribute column.
     
    A shokeyshah, WarHound y Lesh' les gusta esto.
  6. Terrenor

    Terrenor Active Member

    Registrado:
    2 Ene 2019
    Mensajes:
    42
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    26
    Okay I can see your point.
    Sry for my harsh reaction.

    I don't think that this was intended.
    Plasma may be the only combined Ammunition which counts as Normal.
     
  7. Aldo

    Aldo Spare 15

    Registrado:
    23 Nov 2017
    Mensajes:
    1.216
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    1.832
    Are you confirming that Plasma weapons cause 1 arm + 1 bts rolls on Total Immunity models then?
     
  8. ijw

    ijw Ian Wood aka the Wargaming Trader. Rules & Wiki
    Infinity Rules Staff Warcor

    Registrado:
    25 Abr 2017
    Mensajes:
    7.353
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    14.845
    As written, yes, 100%. It's already Normal Ammunition, and there are no relevant Traits to be ignored.

    @HellLois would have to answer whether that's the intention, though.
     
  9. Terrenor

    Terrenor Active Member

    Registrado:
    2 Ene 2019
    Mensajes:
    42
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    26
    But Total immunity says clearly, canceling all special effects and traits, considering it Normal Ammunition.
    The description of Normal ammunition says one Saving roll. For me the special effect of plasma is ARM + BTS saving roll.

    I accept that the rules are not 100 % clear.
     
  10. ijw

    ijw Ian Wood aka the Wargaming Trader. Rules & Wiki
    Infinity Rules Staff Warcor

    Registrado:
    25 Abr 2017
    Mensajes:
    7.353
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    14.845
    It's already Normal Ammunition, though.

    Combined Saving Rolls is not related to that, and is a basic rule that allows weapons to function, not a 'special effects or traits'.

    Like I said, HellLois will have to say whether it's intended or not, but there is no wriggle room in the current rules text.
     
  11. emperorsaistone

    emperorsaistone Well-Known Member

    Registrado:
    30 Nov 2017
    Mensajes:
    830
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    815
    What happens N+EM? N+N then, so only N?
     
  12. Terrenor

    Terrenor Active Member

    Registrado:
    2 Ene 2019
    Mensajes:
    42
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    26
    I take my time to read the rules again.
    My conclusion is that Plasma should have been an ammunitiontyp for it self.

    The rules for Normal ammunition says one saving roll. So Plasma is not Normal ammunition.

    Then Double action although could have been N and 2 x ARM.

    I will wait for an official statement.
    But I can not belief that Plasma is the only weapon immunity total is not effected.
     
  13. Terrenor

    Terrenor Active Member

    Registrado:
    2 Ene 2019
    Mensajes:
    42
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    26
    What happens N+EM? N+N then, so only N?


    Yes, because E/M is non-lethal
    The Trooper is completely immune to Weapons or Ammunitions with the
    Non-Lethal Trait, not suffering their effects, and not requiring a Saving Roll
    or Guts Roll.
     
    A emperorsaistone le gusta esto.
  14. ijw

    ijw Ian Wood aka the Wargaming Trader. Rules & Wiki
    Infinity Rules Staff Warcor

    Registrado:
    25 Abr 2017
    Mensajes:
    7.353
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    14.845
    It isn't an ammunition type, and intentionally isn't.

    Correct, because EM is an Ammunition. Non-Lethal will only be relevant for ranged EM weapons that don't have the N component.
     
  15. Morituri

    Morituri Member

    Registrado:
    6 May 2018
    Mensajes:
    18
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    10
    Agreeing with ijw.

    Looking line by line:
    • Immunity (Total): the Trooper is immune to any Ammunition, cancelling its Special Effects and Traits, considering it Normal Ammunition.

    This isn't being disputed. Plasma isn't an ammo type, and the effect in question isn't an effect from ammo - it is a feature of the weapon itself.

    • The Trooper is completely immune to Traits that cause States, refer to causing Damage, or reduce the Attributes of the target. For example State: Dead, Continuous Damage, or ARM=0.
    Again, the effect in question isn't a trait, and it doesn't cause a state, refer to causing damage, or reduce attributes. It is a "Saving Attribute". Immunity doesn't defy those...

    • The Trooper is completely immune to Weapons or Ammunitions with the Non-Lethal Trait, not suffering their effects, and not requiring a Saving Roll or Guts Roll.
    Not a part of the question...but O-12 isn't happy about this at all...

    Based upon the rules as written, there is nothing to indicate that Immunity (Total) has any effect upon the plasma weapons. It's not the ammunition that produces the Saving Attribute, it is the weapon.
     
    A Lesh' le gusta esto.
  16. specimen_xy

    specimen_xy New Member

    Registrado:
    29 Sep 2020
    Mensajes:
    2
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    0
    So how long does it usually take to get an answer on this sort of thing?
     
  17. ijw

    ijw Ian Wood aka the Wargaming Trader. Rules & Wiki
    Infinity Rules Staff Warcor

    Registrado:
    25 Abr 2017
    Mensajes:
    7.353
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    14.845
    Welcome to the forum!

    It's been answered by multiple posters, and the rule itself isn't ambiguous. Whether the way it currently works is intended is another matter, but that has no bearing on the current wording.
     
    A chromedog y WarHound les gusta esto.
  18. specimen_xy

    specimen_xy New Member

    Registrado:
    29 Sep 2020
    Mensajes:
    2
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    0
    Hey sorry to drag this one up again but can I ask why total immunity works against monofilament weapons? Considering monofilament is also normal ammunition. Sorry if I've missed something obvious.
     
  19. Scarecrow88

    Scarecrow88 Member

    Registrado:
    6 May 2019
    Mensajes:
    25
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    21
    Monofilament causes State: Dead which Immunity (Total) ignores. 2nd sentence under the first bullet point of Immunity (Total).
     
    A Stampysaur y Nuada Airgetlam les gusta esto.
  20. paraelix

    paraelix Seed Embryo Scholar

    Registrado:
    31 Ene 2018
    Mensajes:
    1.163
    Me Gusta recibidos:
    1.206
Estado del tema:
Cerrado para nuevas respuestas
  • About Us

    We are a company founded in 2001 in Cangas (Spain), and devoted to design and manufacture games and figures. Our main product, Infinity the Game, was born with the ambition to satisfy the most demanding audience, offering the best quality.

     

    Why are we here?

     

    Because we are, first and foremost, players.

  • Quick Navigation

    Open the Quick Navigation